As the two or three readers of this blog know, I strongly identify with my Jewish identity and support the state of Israel. I feel that as a member of a people that have lived without a home for thousands of years, and as a result have often seen themselves on the business end of pogroms, genocide and other fun stuff, it is a good thing that there exists a Jewish state in my homeland. Obviously, many people do not share my sentiments. Yes, the Christian crazies (er, I mean evangelists) support Israel for their own self-serving purposes (they are waiting for the
apocalypse or something). and yes, there are plenty of hard-core anti-Semites on the right (the KKK, neo-nazis and militias jump to mind).
But what I want to write about are my fellow travelers on the Left. OK, maybe I'm more of a "liberal" than a leftist, but I have found a lot of the websites and magazines I respect--and link to on this site--are almost reflexively anti-Zionist. I wouldn't say anti-Semetic, because there doesn't seem to be antipathy towards Jews in general. Just the state of Israel and her right to exist.
One example is this
article from In These Times, a magazine I think is great on domestic social and economic issues. And this article this self isn't anti-Zionist per se. It criticizes Derschowitz's
The Case for Israel, a bokk I had some problems with myself. But the comments on the article display a real ignorance and hatred of Israel and its citizens. I have no problem with criticizing a particular government or politician in Israel--I haven't exactly shied away from criticizing Bush. But when people with user names like "israelisarefilth" start condemning most Israelis are uncaring butchers--and he is backed up by half the other commenters--I think there is a problem with the magazine's readership.
I'd love to see commondreams post an article, just once, on the victims of Palestinian suicide bombers, rather than reflexively identifying them as being the only victims. A quick search for Israel on The Nation's
website shows about ten critical articles about Israel, none positive. Sure, these articles are criticizing government policies, but taken together it seems like to the nation's liberal magazine of record, Israel is a pretty bad place indeed.The titles: "What Israel has done", "Israel's failing wall", "The Israel lobby"...you get the picture.
And with almost all of the neocon architects being Jewish, and the whole
AIPAC scandal and all, well critics of this administration are pretty much turning into critics of anyone who supports the
Zionist movement.
In surfing the web, I came across the good
article from Slate dealing with anti-semitism/zionism on the left and why it is so prevelant. The article refers to an article in
Dissent Magazine which is well worth a read. I think it possible to be a liberal, a progressive, a leftist, whatever and still support the existance of a Jewish homeland.